A notice from your homeowners association can turn an ordinary day into a stressful one, especially when it accuses you of something you did not do. Rather than ignoring a notice that is wrong, respond promptly, dispute the allegation in writing, and ask the association to explain the factual and legal basis for its position.
Start With a Written Response
Keep your response factual, professional, and specific. Identify the notice, explain why you dispute it, and ask for:
- The exact provision of the declaration, bylaws, or rules you allegedly violated.
- The date, time, and location of the alleged conduct, and any photographs, reports, or other evidence.
- An explanation of any fine or proposed consequence.
- The process and deadlines for challenging the violation.
Request written confirmation that your dispute was received, and ask the board to suspend enforcement while it reviews the matter rather than assuming an objection puts everything on hold. The goal is a clear record of what the board alleges, what evidence exists, and whether your explanation was addressed.
Read the Documents That Govern Your Community
Review the declaration, master deed, bylaws, rules, and amendments yourself. Focus on three questions: What conduct is prohibited? Who has authority to enforce it? What procedures must the association follow?
In New York, a court invalidated rental restrictions adopted by a homeowners association because they conflicted with rights expressly granted in the condominium governing documents. Olszewski v. Cannon Point Ass’n, Inc., 148 A.D.3d 1306, 1310 (N.Y. App. Div. 2017). In New Jersey, the Supreme Court invalidated a condominium association’s revised parking-fee schedule because it altered an owner’s deed-based property interest without following the required procedures. Thanasoulis v. Winston Towers 200 Ass’n, 110 N.J. 650, 663 (1988). A disagreement with the board does not automatically establish wrongdoing, but the board should be able to identify the authority for its action.
Preserve Evidence and Document Unequal Treatment
Save the notice, correspondence, and photographs, and prepare a timeline while details are fresh. If you believe you are being treated differently, document specific comparable conduct, when it occurred, and how the association responded. In a New York cooperative-board case, the Court of Appeals rejected allegations of personal animosity and selective enforcement as conclusory where the board’s contrary evidence went unrebutted. Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp., 75 N.Y.2d 530, 540 (1990).
New Jersey’s Department of Community Affairs (DCA) advises owners disputing fines to document claims that others are not being fined for the same violation. Keep communications focused on conduct and evidence, not personalities.
Ask About Hearings and Alternative Dispute Resolution
Available procedures depend on state law, the type of association, and the governing documents. In New Jersey, the Condominium Act and the Planned Real Estate Development Full Disclosure Act require covered associations to provide a fair and efficient alternative to litigation, commonly called alternative dispute resolution (ADR), for qualifying housing-related disputes. New Jersey condominium law also bars a fine unless the owner receives written notice of the action and its basis and is advised of the right to participate in dispute resolution; that requirement is not a universal rule for every HOA in every state.
Ask for the written procedure, including how a neutral is selected and whether the outcome is binding. In a New Jersey condominium case, the appellate court held that ADR need not be exhausted before filing suit, although a court ordinarily should refer a filed dispute to ADR if a party requests it and no compelling circumstances warrant proceeding. Finderne Hgts. v. Rabinowitz, 390 N.J. Super. 154, 163–64 (App. Div. 2007).
Want Different Board Members? Start With Elections
A disputed violation may be a symptom of a larger governance problem. If your goal is to change the board’s direction, elections may be the most practical route, and the DCA recognizes them as an important means of addressing disagreements with discretionary board decisions. Review nomination procedures, voting eligibility, meeting requirements, and deadlines. In a New York condominium election case, the court upheld nominations from the floor under the applicable bylaws and found the board’s pre-meeting notice of the opportunity to run fair and effective. Liberty Court Condominium Residential Unit Owners Coalition v. Board of Managers of Liberty Court Condominium, 3 A.D.3d 443 (N.Y. App. Div. 2004).
New Jersey regulations impose specific election requirements in covered communities. In a New Jersey townhouse-association dispute, the appellate court found that a board exceeded its authority by issuing a partisan audit of election candidates that the governing documents did not authorize. Verna v. Links at Valleybrook Neighbor, 371 N.J. Super. 77, 91–93 (App. Div. 2004).
Election Versus Removal
Voting against a board member when a term expires is different from removing that person early. Before circulating a petition, have the governing documents and law reviewed for the required authority, notice, voting threshold, and procedures; a procedural mistake can shift attention to the validity of the removal effort.
When Legal Action May Be Necessary
Some disputes, such as denied access to records, failures to follow governing documents, or alleged financial misconduct, cannot be resolved through correspondence, ADR, or elections. New York courts defer to authorized, good-faith condominium board decisions made in furtherance of legitimate condominium interests rather than substituting their own judgment. Schoninger v. Yardarm Beach, 134 A.D.2d 1, 9–10 (N.Y. App. Div. 1987). In New Jersey, the DCA’s Association Regulation Unit can require an association to provide an ADR procedure, but it does not conduct ADR, decide the merits, or hear appeals. An attorney can help separate a disagreement over judgment from a violation of an enforceable obligation.
Protect Your Rights Without Escalating Unnecessarily
An incorrect HOA notice deserves a response, not a heated argument. If the problem goes beyond one violation, consider an election, a properly authorized removal effort, or legal action aimed at a specific violation of your rights.
At The Law Office of Barry E. Janay, P.C., we help homeowners evaluate association disputes and develop a strategy suited to the documents, the facts, and their goals.
This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Rights and procedures vary by state, association type, governing documents, and the circumstances of the dispute.
Barry E. Janay, Esq. is a seasoned New York and New Jersey attorney with over 20 years of legal experience, focusing on estate planning, probate, business law, and complex legal matters. As the founder of The Law Office of Barry E. Janay, he provides strategic, results-driven legal guidance to individuals and businesses navigating high-stakes decisions.
Barry has served as senior counsel and general counsel across multiple industries, bringing deep expertise in regulatory compliance, contracts, and corporate strategy. Known for his direct, no-nonsense approach, he helps clients resolve legal challenges efficiently while protecting their long-term interests.
He is admitted to practice in New York, New Jersey, and multiple federal courts, and has been recognized for his professional excellence and client-focused advocacy.